This page is a listing of all the players who have worn the number "37" for the Toronto Blue Jays, and for what years.
- Brian Bowles (2001-2002)
- Tim Crabtree (1995-1997)
- Scott Downs (2005-2009)
- Reed Johnson (2003-2004)
- Graeme Lloyd (1999)
- Randy St. Claire (1994)
- Dave Stieb (1979-1992, 1998)
- Henderson Alvarez (2011-2012)
Aaron Laffey (2013 - )[]
An asterisk ( " * " ) denotes that the number was shared between two or more players during that year.