This page is a listing of all the players who have worn the number "58" for the Toronto Blue Jays, and for what years.
- Josh Banks (2007)
- Brad Cornett (1994)
- John Gibbons - as Manager (2004)
- Dirk Hayhurst (2009)
- Shannon Withem (1998)
An asterisk ( " * " ) denotes that the number was shared between two or more players during that year.